Summary Capsule
Mutant Meter
Movie Store [proceeds go toward monthly MRFH upkeep]
Seriously, just… wow. It’s been over an hour since I walked out of my first (and definitely not last) viewing of Spider-Man 2 in the theater, and I still haven’t come down yet — always a good sign. Before I start gushing, though, I guess it’s my duty, as an unbiased (pfftt) reviewer, to list the negative qualities. (I’ll make it quick, promise.)
You can tell that Raimi is looser and more inclined to play around this time, as seen in the Evil Dead-inspired hospital scene. (Chainsaws and mechanical appendages… YES!) Everything about the movie is just bigger and better: more web-slinging, more gags (the elevator scene is priceless), more intensity, and best of all for mutant readers, more Bruce Campbell! Yeah, Bruce, you keep Peter out of that theater! Ahem. Speaking of Tobey Maguire, the boy was just born to play Peter Parker, and that’s all there is to it. Nerdy yet powerful, optimistic but incessantly put-upon… he might’ve benefited from having a few more wisecracks as Spidey, but that’s not his fault. Kirsten Dunst, meanwhile, continues to be pretty and to look very good in tight clothing, which is all I need. For the rest of you, her Mary Jane builds nicely upon the past and continues to grow as a character, wanting to figure Peter out but staying well clear of the Lois Lane stereotype. Extra credit for that final shot, contrasting Peter’s joy in being Spider-Man with what we can plainly see from her face is the first of many a long, worrisome night for MJ. Then we have the supporting characters. J.K. Simmons nails J. Jonah Jameson, of course, getting more screentime and even better lines this time around. (And upon his sudden change of heart about Spider-Man — and then immediate shift back — the inner geek in me couldn’t help but think, “That’s exactly what he would’ve done in the comics!”) His son doesn’t get to do much, but whatever, he’s just there to look pretty anyway. Rosemary Harris brings the right mixture of sweet old lady and spitfire to Aunt May; to be honest, I was expecting her character to be quietly shuffled off to the sidelines, but she had a significant role and did very well with it. I’d talk about James Franco, but I’m sure Clare will write at least 3 paragraphs about the former Freaks and Geeks star hitting it big, so I’ll just say that he captures Harry’s deteriorating friendship with Peter (and mental state) terrifically. I won’t give away the ending, but his final discovery has me looking forward to Spider-Man 3 more than words can say. (Now, what begins with an "H" and ends with an "H"…) Bringing a comic-book villain to life on the big screen is no easy task, as any director will tell you — for every Hackman or Nicholson, there’s about a dozen Schwarzeneggers. The fact is, most of us grew up seeing these guys emblazoned on lunchboxes and backpacks, and impotently shaking their fists and shouting death threats on Saturday morning cartoons. Thus, it’s easy for us to forget just how menacing and unnerving most of them would actually be in real life. A man with four mechanical octopus arms might sound funny when you first hear about it, but seeing it come to life on the big screen? I’ll say this — in my theater, nobody was laughing. Major, major props to the special effects team; Doc Ock’s arms don’t just look believable in every single frame they’re in, they genuinely seem to have a personality of their own, something even the comic never accomplished. And what can I say about Alfred Molina, except that he brings a level of intensity and danger to the role that I never felt from the Green Goblin last time out. (Note: Willem Dafoe still rules all.) More than that, though, he makes us realize that for all of Octavius’s villainy, he was a good man at one point — a bit arrogant, too caught up in his work, but decent nonetheless. I love it when actors take their comic-book roles seriously, and Molina deserves all the credit in the world for a terrific performance. When all is said and done, you just have to reflect on what makes for a truly great Spider-Man story, then compare it to how many of those elements were included in the movie. Human angle that focuses more on Peter Parker, everyman with real-world problems, than some invincible guy in a costume? Yep. Cool but tragic villain with ties to both Spider-Man and Peter? Absolutely. Spidey using his brain and his heart, rather than his fists, to beat said bad guy? Oh yeah. Jameson blustering, Aunt May doting, Peter having terrible luck, and Mary Jane saying “Tiger”? Check, check, check, and double check, true believer. It all adds up to a winner in my book, folks… now, bring on Spidey 3!
And now, two years later, I get the most rude awakening possible. The Spidey sequel I’ve been waiting so anxiously for is that most-feared word that I never thought I’d apply to ol’ Webhead… it’s BORING. But back up the truck a minute, we’ll go over what the movie’s all about first, and then we’ll get to the heartbreak. Set nearly two years after the first film, Spidey 2 finds poor Peter Parker all caught up in his own web. Two years of college, job hunting, deflecting the affections of the woman he loves, living in a slum, and fighting crime in the streets of New York has not been kind to our hero. He’s losing ground on everything in his life… he loses his pizza job, he’s flunking out at school, and he’s managed to alienate Mary Jane to the point that she no longer consider him even a friend. Making matters worse, J. Jonah Jameson has tirelessly worked to soil his name via the Daily Bugle, and his best friend Harry not only swears vengeance on “the bug” for killing his father, he pressures Peter constantly to provide the superhero’s identity to him. And is if all that wasn’t enough, Spidey finds his powers starting to fade on him… his web glands no longer fire reliably (a bad thing when the web’s the only thing holding him high off the ground), his leaping abilities start to shorten up, and even the improvement in his eyesight starts to fade. In short: Peter’s tired of this crap. So, in what can only be charitably described as a near photocopy of Superman II’s “Clark gives up” storyline, Peter throws in the towel and decides to dedicate his energy to living life as a civilian. And for a while, it works. We see Peter enjoying being a student again. He manages to get back into MJ’s good books. Harry still hates him, but hey! Two out of three ain’t bad, right? With the spider out of his life, Parker suddenly starts enjoying the simple things again. Sure enough though, it can’t last. When a new villain arises to make NYC his personal stomping ground, Peter has to make his choice: can he really throw away the responsibility and the power that no one else can use? I’ll give you a hint: the movie’s not called Peter Parker 2. There’s a lot of refinements over the original movie. CGI Spidey, an integral part of making the action in both films, has improved leaps and bounds. The plasticky look of Spider-Man 1’s protagonist is much, much less noticeable. As he jumps and swings around NYC, you’ll be a lot less distracted by the visibly apparent fakeness of it. He’s just so much more fluid, so much more realistic. The new villain this time out, the legendary Doctor Octopus, also looks fantastic… not as graceful as Spidey (he shouldn’t be), but grittier and tougher. The improvement in the action scenes is a natural to follow, as the eye is less inclined to play “Spot the special effects” and more likely to play “Holy crap, look at those two smack the hell out of each other as they plummet hundreds of floors to the streets!”. It’s a real treat. The moments of the movie I really enjoyed were, naturally, the ones that concentrated on the two main characters, Spidey and Doc Ock. Both characters are just tremendous fun to watch, especially for the creative use of their powers. Spidey you should know well enough, but in case you’re in the dark on Octopus, he’s a scientist driven mad after having four giant mechanical tentacles grafted onto his back in the same accident that killed his beloved wife. And everyone is very well acted… Alfred Molina particularly deserves credit for turning Doc Ock into such a tragic and believable character. Tobey Maguire is still good as Peter/Spidey (more on that in a minute, though…). Kirsten Dunst has pretty much worn out her welcome to me, though… MJ was always this incredibly cool, in-control girl that usually managed to flummox Peter in every sense in the comics. Here she’s flatter, less interesting… she’s just the neighbour’s girl. Sure, she’s got the figure for a comic book heroine, but couldn’t we hurry up and get to Black Cat or something? Sheesh. However, as much as I enjoyed the action and acting in SM2, I have to call a spade a spade. This movie is just stagnantly boring in the middle act. I am all about the humanity of Spidey’s character, it’s one of the things that draw me to his story, but enough is enough. The entire middle third of the movie is a soap opera. Who will MJ marry? Will Harry continue to haunt his father’s killer? Should Peter have given up the costume? Can I stay awake till the end? They start throwing in interspersed shots of Doc Ock rebuilding his failed experiments in case you thought you’d wandered into Dawson’s Creek: The Next Generation. Honestly, the whole film’s web just undoes in the middle. We’re treated to corny speech after corny speech with nary an oasis of humour or action to help us out. The pathos is just unfathomable, and it’s all stretched so thin it threatens to break. Thankfully, Spidey slaps the red n’ blues back on in time to meet Doc Ock head-on, but we already knew that would happen… why torment the audience with so much slow drama? If you’re a Spidey-fan, you do owe it to yourself to check out Spider Man 2. It’s simply too delicious to watch Webs go up against Octopus to pass it up, but the framework of the rest of the movie is nearly too frail. I honestly can’t recommend against it, but I can’t believe that I can’t wholeheartedly endorse it, either. Ah well. At least Rich will be excited for the return of the Green Goblin. Heh heh…
I think the answer lies both in my decades of reading comic books (with an undeniably heavy emphasis on Spider-Man, especially in my formative years) and in my personal regard for superheroes. See, I’ve read years worth of Peter Parker living the loser life, so I didn’t need to see it so painstakingly replicated on the big-screen. That said, I think his loserdom was a little too over-the-top, with Peter being way too downtrodden and weighed down by his super-burden. You ever heard of balance, my man? If Mary Jane is fed up with you, go with the hot skinny girl bearing chocolate cake and milk. If you’re too tired, let the cops deal with tonight’s bank robber and get some shut-eye. You can wake up early and save New York City in the morning. But I think the decision to make Peter such a burdened loser loner was to balance out the great power he received so easily, so the audience wouldn’t begrudge him. Sure, it sucks that you lost your uncle, kid, but you get to swing around Manhattan and bench-press Buicks! I’d love to be you, a kid might think, but watching Spider-Man 2 it’s tough to imagine anyone would want to be him. That’s connected with the Marvel Comics depiction of heroes, where they are seldom the godly, well-adjusted (other than Batman) superheroes of DC Comics and more just high-powered angsty good guys who are careful never to abuse their powers and suffer just as much, if not more, than they ever bask in glory. All of which is to say that a huge part of my disillusion with both Spider-Man movies (but especially the sequel) is that they successfully carried over the hard knocks and hard luck of Parker’s post-atomic-arachnid, but left any sense of personal accomplishment and enjoyment behind on the printed page. And make no mistake, the Parker/Spidey of the comics does a much better job of reconciling with the derision and scorn he gets from J. Jonah Jameson and the non-powered NYC citizens, and by enjoying the fact that he gets to get away from it all high above the city he loves. The comics’ Peter seems truly capable of loving Mary Jane, and of loving the life he has, great responsibilities and tragic losses included. The cinematic Peter, played to wide-eyed “I use magic to fool you into thinking I’m an incredible actor even though I only have one expression” effect by Tobey Maguire, seems so downtrodden and hollowed-out that it’s hard for me to believe he finds the spider-strength to get out of the bed in the morning, let alone stop himself from spinning a web-noose and hanging himself. Just let go, Peter! But I can pontificate all I want about these details. The biggest reason I don’t care to ever watch Spider-Man 2 again is that it’s strangely distant and exceedingly boring for my tastes. I don’t know if I don’t like Maguire or Kirsten Dunst as thespians or what, but the tepid romance they try to engage in held no interest for me whatsoever. I think even the biggest loser wallflower could stammer something to keep a dying ember burning a little longer, so Peter’s inability to even raise an eyebrow to indicate interest was really infuriating. And hey, we get Parker is supposed to be a huge loser with bad luck, we don’t need to see him living in squalor and not getting any champagne and stepping in gum and having to sew his costume and losing his powers and losing his hair and missing the bus and not getting in to see MJ’s show. We get it. Can we get some web-slinging scenes, please? I could mention the fights, or Doctor Octopus (if he’s on-screen, it’s slightly cool, if he’s not, d'oh!), or when Peter turns into Jesus Christ on the passenger train (as my friend e puts it: “Peter Parker died for your sins, Octavius”). But it’s not worth it. I’m raising these criticisms so maybe future superhero movies (or any movies, for that matter) will try new things and new forms of synthesis without depowering or devaluing the original concepts. Here’s hoping. Meanwhile, if you’re wondering if you should bother seeing Spider-Man 2 at all, let me ask you this: does the prospect of seeing Bruce Campbell for about 30 seconds playing a recalcitrant theater doorman who denies Peter entry to MJ’s play sound remotely entertaining or even interesting to you? If so, Spider-Man 2 is probably exactly your cup of tea. If not, hey, there’s hope for you! Get some Grant Morrison-written comic books and read ‘em, stat!
Is It Worth Staying Through End Credits?
A Brief Comic Book History Of Spider-Man
Spider-Man is perhaps the most human of all superhero characters, maintaining both a normal, human life and a crime-fighting life. Also, unlike many superheroes, Spider-Man has a terrific sense of humor, and his quips are part of his trademark. The final big difference between Spidey and most heroes is that for much of the comic books, Peter Parker is a married man (to Mary Jane). In the comics, high school student Peter Parker's parents were killed in a plane crash, and he grew up with his Aunt May and Uncle Ben. He was bitten by a radioactive spider and receives certain spider-like benefits: quick reflexes, increased strength (able to lift around 10 tons), the ability to climb walls and jump far (around 3 stories high), and the infamous "Spider Sense" (which lets him know if something is amiss). As a scientist, Peter built his own web-flinging canisters. His guilt over the criminal death of his Uncle Ben urged Peter to fight crime, and he supplimented his income by taking photographs of Spider-Man and selling it to the Daily Bugle. The roster of Spider-Man's enemies have included the Green Goblin, the Rocket Racer, the Lizard, Venom, Carnage, Doc Ock, The Chameleon, Electro, Man-Wolf, The Sandman, The Scorpion and The Vulture. Intermission! [some sources: IMDb]
The storyline is loosely adapted from The Amazing Spider-Man #3 (origin of Doctor Octopus) and #50, “Spider-Man… No More!” The shot of Peter dumping his Spider-Man costume in an alley trash can is identical to a famous panel from that latter issue. For a scene featuring fighting on the exterior of a subway train amidst a crowd of skyscrapers, portions of this film were filmed in Chicago, Illinois on the famous elevated "Loop" standing in for New York City's 9th St. El in Manhattan, torn down in 1940, with routes transferred to underground subway lines. Chicago 'el' trains were made up to appear as 'R'-train cars complete with MTA New York City Subway decals and 'Bay Ridge' on their destination board. Filming began before an official script was completed. In Alfred Molina's first film, Raiders of the Lost Ark , he was required to let spiders crawl all over his body. He was Indiana Jones guide into the first cave (the "Throw me the idol" guy). On June 30, 2004, the film broke a record for highest one-day opening on a Wednesday to date: $40,442,604 This movie sets up the potential arrival of several classic Spider Man villains to come in sequels: Man Wolf (John Jamison), the Lizard (Dr Connors), Venom (courtesy of John’s trip into space), and the most obvious of all, the Green Goblin, or perhaps the Hobgoblin (Harry Osbourne). PoolMan hereby recommends the Spider Man 2 game on the GameCube (and PS2 and Xbox). It is to DIE for. It’s as close as we’re going to get for some time to the real thing until 3M starts making webshooters for the rest of us! Just avoid the PC version… it’s NOT the same game. Groovy Quotes
Doc Ock: Find him. Or I will peel he flesh off her bones...
May Parker: You'll never guess who he wants to be... Spider-Man!
J. Jonah Jameson: I'll give you $150.00 for it!
Mary Jane Watson: Go get 'em, tiger. Witness: Whoa... He just stole that dude's pizzas!
J. Jonah Jameson: Call Debra.
Elevator Passenger: Nice Spidey outfit...
Mr. Ditkovich: If promises were crackers, my daughter would be fat.
Peter Parker: Mr. Jameson, please, isn't there any of these shots you can use? I really need the money.
J. Jonah Jameson: Parker! You're fired!
Woman at Web: Go, Spidey, go! Man on Train: [looking at Peter without his mask] He's... just a... kid. No older than my son. Doc Ock: The power of the sun, in the palm of my hand!
Miss Brant: Sir, your wife called. She said she lost your checkbook.
Mr. Ditkovich: Rent!
Peter Parker: Uncle Ben died that night for being the only one who did the right thing. Mary Jane: So here I am standing in your doorway... I've always been standing in your doorway. Mary Jane: Go get 'em, tiger! If you liked this movie, try these:
This review page was last updated on 1.19.05 MRFH Home . Reviews . Findaflik . Features! . MRFH Forum © 2005 Mutant Reviewers From Hell (Original Content). All Rights Reserved. |